December 2, 2023

In Alberta, Saskatchewan, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, fossil fuels are a big a part of the electrical energy combine — which makes hitting the 2035 goal troublesome

Article content material

The Liberal authorities has introduced new laws that might power provinces to make sure they’ve net-zero electrical energy grids by 2035.

For a number of provinces, this isn’t a large deal. British Columbia and Quebec have already got appreciable quantities of hydro energy, for instance, and Ontario and Newfoundland and Labrador even have lower-emissions electrical energy programs.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

However, it’s much less easy in 4 provinces: Alberta, Saskatchewan, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia. In these provinces, fossil fuels make up a big a part of the electrical energy combine.

Whereas the politics of this alteration are related — Alberta and Saskatchewan’s leaders are extremely opposed — so, too, are among the monetary and technological challenges that might have to be overcome to attain what the Liberal authorities needs.

The Nationwide Submit spoke to Andrew Leach, a College of Alberta power and environmental economist, to get a proof of what, precisely, is occurring with the clear electrical energy laws. This dialog has been condensed and edited for readability and size.

What precisely is going on?

Mainly, what (the Liberals are) doing is setting end-of-life circumstances or prohibitions on utilizing pure fuel and oil to generate electrical energy in all however sure circumstances.

So, if in case you have different sources of electrical energy that generate greenhouse gases, you’re going to need to, as an influence generator, as a Crown corp. or what have you ever, discover different sources of energy by the point these amenities attain what the laws outline as their finish of life — which is both 2035 or 20 years after they arrive into service.

Commercial 3

Article content material

So if in case you have, say, a pure fuel plant that went on-line in 2023, it may keep on-line till 2043?


(Liberal Surroundings Minister Steven) Guilbeault is getting criticized for these “loopholes” by the environmental motion, for permitting various kinds of fuel era, for not simply merely prohibiting pure fuel and oil era. And naturally from Alberta, they’re saying there’s no flexibility, the lights are going to go off in 2035.

And there’s really fairly vital flexibility within the (laws).

How are the Liberals really going to implement this?

There’s carrots and sticks.

So the clean-electricity laws that got here out final week, these are created below the Canadian Environmental Safety Act. And so it’s federal environmental laws, and that is an add-on regulation below that piece of laws. Beforehand, laws made below that environmental safety (legislation) have been challenged.

The courts decided that these have been legitimate federal laws below Parliament’s capability to enact felony legal guidelines.

Commercial 4

Article content material

It’s not a part of the Prison Code, but it surely’s laws that has the attribute of felony legislation. In order that’s inside the powers of the federal authorities.

This most likely varies by province, however the place is Canada at by way of reaching a net-zero electrical energy grid?

The crux of the problem is that you’ve grids which might be (pretty) web zero already or programs which might be (pretty) web zero already in Quebec and Manitoba and B.C. After which Ontario, you have got fairly a low emission system, (and) Newfoundland and Labrador.

However then you definately get into New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Alberta and Saskatchewan and issues are very, very totally different.

And so you have got far more emissions-intensive programs and definitely within the case of Alberta and Saskatchewan, and to a point in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia as nicely, you have got programs that aren’t built-in with different markets. So that they’re kind of electrical energy islands, and on these islands, there’s little or no electrical energy producing capability that doesn’t come from coal, pure fuel.

Might Alberta, say, toss up some dams for hydro energy?

There may be hydro potential within the north and Slave River however there’s vital environmental considerations and, after all, First Nations considerations with respect to damming that.

Commercial 5

Article content material

The Peace Nation doubtless has some potential, however once more, that’s one thing that we haven’t exploited in the identical method as different jurisdictions have. And , we haven’t needed to as a result of … we’re sitting on an island of pure fuel, so for probably the most half, pure fuel energy has been traditionally low cost for us.

How may Alberta, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick meet the federal government’s targets?

It’s very totally different tales in every of these provinces.

It might imply constructing carbon seize and sequestration on, more than likely, a few of their current crops. That will imply some new amenities. It might most likely imply an extended, arduous take a look at nuclear power in Saskatchewan.

And it will imply extra wind and photo voltaic, it will imply extra interconnection to different electrical energy programs with extra hydro potential, perhaps it will imply hydro in northern Saskatchewan.

To what extent is that this even potential?

Yeah, I imply, all of it activates what’s your definition of potential. We have now a bunch on the College of Alberta that I’m a part of, and we run an hourly electrical energy mannequin of Alberta.

And we will create a net-zero Alberta electrical energy system by doing numerous these issues I simply talked about — extra connection to B.C. carbon seize and storage crops/hydrogen energy crops, much more wind, a bit bit extra photo voltaic, some storage, and you can also make it work.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Nevertheless it’s a radically totally different era sector than the one which we’ve proper now.

And it ideas the steadiness from a minimal capital funding and numerous expense to working. Now you’re transferring to numerous installations which might be extra capital intensive — photo voltaic panels, wind generators, batteries that don’t price you numerous to function, however they price you numerous up entrance.

So it’s a change in the best way and the sorts of funding, in the best way that funding would occur.

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a energetic however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We have now enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail should you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra info and particulars on find out how to alter your e mail settings.

Be part of the Dialog