December 2, 2023

Two individuals who participated within the brutal kidnapping of an Indigenous girl forcibly dosed with fentanyl till she died will study subsequent month how lengthy they have to serve in jail

Article content material

Warning: This story accommodates particulars some readers could discover disturbing. 

Two individuals who participated within the brutal kidnapping of an Indigenous girl forcibly dosed with fentanyl till she died will study subsequent month how lengthy they have to serve in jail. 

Article content material

Tuesday noticed the conclusion of a sentencing listening to within the case of Tyra Muskego and Buddy Underwood, who had been convicted of manslaughter and second-degree homicide, respectively, within the demise of Nature Duperron.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Underwood faces a compulsory sentence of life in jail with no likelihood of parole for no less than 10 years. The Crown is asking the parole ineligibility interval be prolonged to 22 years, whereas the defence is suggesting 15.

Muskego faces no obligatory sentence. The Crown is asking she be sentenced to fifteen years in jail whereas the defence is asking for 5 to 9 years.

Justice Robert Graesser is predicted to provide his choice Sept. 11.

Two co-accused, Grayson Eashappie and Kala Bajusz, pleaded responsible to second-degree homicide final fall and had been every sentenced to life in jail with no likelihood of parole for 15 years. All 4 had been initially charged with first-degree homicide

Eashappie admitted to injecting Duperron with fentanyl no less than 3 times earlier than the group dumped her, close to demise, within the woods almost 300 km west of Edmonton. A toxicologist stated her reason for demise was fentanyl and methamphetamine toxicity. Courtroom heard she additionally had been force-fed fentanyl.

In a press release learn by defence lawyer Paul Moreau, Muskego, 25, stated she takes duty for her position within the “nightmare.”

Commercial 3

Article content material

“I’m so sorry,” she instructed Duperron’s household. “I do know my sorries could imply nothing to you nevertheless it’s all I may give you.” 

She added, “I used to be misplaced in dependancy and nonetheless a child, homeless, alone and naive.” 

Duperron, 25, was a loving mom of three and an enormous sister with “a reminiscence like an elephant,” mom Cheryl Uchytil stated in a sufferer impression assertion. Her daughter was “very loveable” and “light in character,” but in addition exhausting on herself. She started utilizing and ultimately promoting medication after traumatic occasions in her younger life. For some time, she stopped and was making a “comeback,” her mom stated, however ultimately moved to Edmonton and fell in with the flawed crowd.  


Bret Desjarlais, Underwood’s cousin and the star Crown witness, stated he met Duperron after an evening of partying with Underwood, Muskego, Eashappie and Bajusz. He instructed court docket he wanted cash and agreed to drive Duperron round in his truck whereas she delivered medication. In some unspecified time in the future, Underwood warned him they had been planning to rob Duperron.

Commercial 4

Article content material

Desjarlais stated Duperron was compelled into the truck, crushed after which pushed round city earlier than being launched in one other location. The 2 ladies rifled by means of Duperron’s purse, however ordered Desjarlais to return for Duperron once they discovered nothing inside.

Ultimately, they discovered Duperron close to an ATM kiosk on Kingsway. Muskego and Bajusz chased her down and dragged her again to the truck. They shoved her onto the ground of the again seat the place Muskego, Bajusz and Eashappie kicked and beat her whereas they drove round city. 

A body discovered outside Hinton in May, 2019 has now been identified as Nature Duperron.
Nature Duperron’s physique was found exterior Hinton in Could 2019. Provided

Ultimately, Underwood made the “name” that Duperron knew an excessive amount of and instructed Desjarlais to drive out of city. They made stops for gasoline and alcohol as they drove west on Freeway 16, ultimately injecting Duperron with fentanyl, handcuffing her and abandoning her within the bush close to Freeway 40 exterior Hinton.

Desjarlais, haunted by what occurred, fell deeper into dependancy and ultimately went to police. He led police to Duperron’s physique the next month after she was reported lacking and signed an immunity settlement with authorities. The 4 co-accused had been charged with first-degree homicide however pleaded or had been discovered responsible of lesser offences.

Commercial 5

Article content material

Graesser stated he faces a “very troublesome” sentencing choice given the case includes two Indigenous folks convicted of killing an Indigenous girl.

Each Underwood (who stays in custody) and Muskego (who was launched on bail) filed Gladue experiences detailing how authorities coverage towards Indigenous folks could have contributed to their offending.

Mark Jordan, Underwood’s lawyer, stated his shopper grew up in an atmosphere of abuse and neglect owing partly to his household’s residential college expertise.

“He felt like no one needed him when he was younger,” Jordan stated, saying that’s what led partly to his meth abuse. Muskego, from Onion Lake, additionally suffered because of her household’s time in residential colleges, Moreau stated.

Crown prosecutor Marissa Tordoff stated that have to be weighed in opposition to the “epidemic” of violence in opposition to Indigenous ladies in Canada.

She stated Underwood “was the directing thoughts of the group,” who made the choice to show off into the woods and go away Duperron to die. She famous he had a gun, regardless of being beneath a court docket order to not possess firearms.

Tordoff stated that whereas Graesser in the end concluded the homicide was not premeditated, Underwood’s actions had been “as near a first-degree homicide as a second-degree homicide will get.”

Underwood declined to deal with the court docket.

[email protected]

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We now have enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail for those who obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a person you comply with feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra data and particulars on the way to alter your e mail settings.

Be a part of the Dialog