February 29, 2024

Feds are paying $520K to retailer the ‘lifeless’ ship partly capsized by suspected vandals in 2018

Article content material

OTTAWA – The federal authorities paid $520,000 to a Nova Scotia shipyard proprietor to retailer a “lifeless” Coast Guard ship, the identical shipyard proprietor being sued by the federal government for negligence as a result of it was repairing the vessel when it was ruined by vandals 5 years in the past.

In November 2018, staff at Canadian Maritime Engineering’s Sambro, N.S., shipyard arrived to work to discover a stunning scene. 

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

The CCGS Corporal McLaren, a five-year-old, Hero-class Canadian Coast Guard ship that was being refit by the corporate sat partially capsized and submerged within the frigid waters of Sambro Harbour, the primary and secondary help cables that meant to carry it upright hanging loosely off the aspect of the vessel.

Halifax police shortly decided the harm was seemingly brought on by vandals who walked onto the positioning, which had no fencing in keeping with stories by World Information, and minimize the help cables. The alleged vandals might have dedicated the proper crime, as police affirm that they’ve since closed the case with out laying any expenses.

In whole, the practically new ship suffered $14 million in harm as the results of suspected vandalism, in keeping with an announcement of declare filed by the federal authorities towards Canadian Maritime Engineering (CME) in early 2021.

“The Vessel would require main repairs involving the alternative of practically all electrical and mechanical techniques in addition to the lodging to re-store it to its state previous to the incident,” reads the declare. 

Commercial 3

Article content material

“The harm to the vessel was as a result of negligence of CME,” which “didn’t safe the vessel” from harm, theft or unauthorized entry and “failed to keep up steady safety across the clock,” provides the declare.

Canadian Maritime Engineering and its president, Tony Kennedy, didn’t reply to a number of requests for remark by deadline.

In its assertion of defence, CME denied any accountability and stated that it acted “moderately” and “took applicable care” of the ship always. It additionally argued that the vandalism prompted “important” harm to the corporate’s tools and blocked entry to its fundamental slipway, inflicting it “important financial loss.”

Practically one 12 months after the vandalism, Public Service and Procurement Canada (PSPC) cancelled the restore contract with CME and finally ferried the CCGS Corporal McLaren to the close by Bedford Institute of Oceanography (BIO) in Dartmouth, N.S.

However by 2022, the BIO wanted the “lifeless ship” out of its yard attributable to “house necessities and pending upgrades,” in keeping with procurement paperwork from PSPC. The Coast Guard had not determined if it will restore or salvage what remained of the ship but, so PSPC put out a public tender for drydocking and storage of the CCGS Corporal McLaren for no less than one 12 months.

Commercial 4

Article content material

On July 26, the division awarded the $503,000 contract to the Pictou Shipyard owned by CME, the identical firm that owns the Sambro website the place the vessel was broken within the first place. The worth of the contract was later elevated to $520,000.

“CME Sambro shipyard and CME Pictou Shipyard are two separate enterprise entities in terms of bidding on federal authorities contracts,” PSPC spokesperson Jeremy Hyperlink stated in an electronic mail.

Hyperlink additionally stated CME’s Sambro shipyard was briefly barred from federal contracts (for six months) following the CCGS Corporal McLaren points, however has been re-eligible to bid since December 2020.

In line with two procurement specialists, the very fact the federal government is as soon as once more entrusting the ship to the proprietor of the shipyard the place it suffered $14 million in damages ranges from “ironic” to “foolish.”

Alan Williams, a former assistant deputy minister for Materiel on the Division of Nationwide Defence, says the corporate ought to have been blacklisted from ever touching the ship once more from the get-go.

It sounds silly, it makes all people look foolish when you may have these items occurring after they ought to not.

Alan Williams, former assistant deputy minister for Materiel on the Division of Nationwide Defence

“One would have thought that in case you’re issuing a contract for some firm to retailer a ship that has been vandalized in a shipyard, one of many standards you’ll need to search for when it comes to the qualification of the yard is, ‘Have you ever had any ships vandalized below your management?’” Williams stated in an interview.

Commercial 5

Article content material

“And one would have thought that anyone that had such a state of affairs happen below their management can be disqualified,” he added. “It sounds silly, it makes all people look foolish when you may have these items occurring after they ought to not.”

Veteran procurement and defence analyst Martin Shadwick questioned why the federal government couldn’t discover one other shipyard to retailer the vessel.

“The typical taxpayer will take a look at this and marvel what’s occurring right here,” he stated. “The Navy is so small in the mean time, I’m stunned that they wouldn’t have had house for it. The vessel is just not that giant, it’s 43 meters, and we’re sort of in need of naval vessels in the mean time.”

Put into service in 2013, the CCGS Corporal McLaren will now have spent roughly half of its life as a “lifeless boat.” In an announcement, Fisheries and Ocean Canada (which oversees the coast guard) spokesperson Robin Jahn stated the group continues to be making an attempt to determine what it’ll do with the ship.

“The Canadian Coast Guard is exploring all choices relating to the way forward for the ship. This features a complete evaluation of the prices and advantages to restore,” Jahn stated in an electronic mail.

Our web site is the place for the most recent breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our day by day e-newsletter, Posted, right here.

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We have now enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra data and particulars on how you can modify your electronic mail settings.

Be a part of the Dialog